The Non-Jewish Individual Essay -- Jewish History, Kafka

The Non-Jewish IndividualJewish history is a study of a people in exile. Since the destruction of the Temple of Jerusalem, the experience of the Jewish individual in relation to non-Jewish confederation has often been that of an outsider looking in. In addition, the searching Jewish culture, religion, and philosophy identifiably marked the Jews as a separate people. Although this demarcation exposed the Jews to many negative ideological trends, Isaac Deutschers The Non-Jewish Jew argues that this marginalization enabled the spectacular thinkers of the 19th and 20th centuries to revolutionize the European continent. As the title suggests, the non-Jewish Jews were individuals that abandoned Judaism. Deutscher argues that the historical exclusion imbued Jewish people with the innate perspective of the external critic. When the individuals emancipated themselves from the ideological shackles of Judaism this now double marginalization provided the perspective of the extreme outsider. O nce freed from both the restrictions of Jewish and Christian political theory they were then able to reinterpret society and develop the theories that would revolutionize the world. Deutscher asserts that the famous non-Jewish Jews such as Spinoza, Heine, Marx, and others were representatives of this perspective. In essence, their independence from society enabled them to criticize and fundamentally change the ideological landscape of Europe in ways that other thinkers bound by Christian or Jewish ideology could not. However, with an analysis of Deutschers argument through Franz Kafkas A state to an Academy it becomes clear that his Non-Jewish Jews were not only dependent upon society, but also more importantly they were not actually Jewish. Initially, Kakfas ... ...by the subjects of Deutschers The Non-Jewish Jew are reflected and exhibited in Deutschers work. His assertion that Jews have a special ability to critically analyze society because of their historical isolation suppo rts the same race based ideology that the historical figures worked against. Additionally, the association of Marx, Heine, and the others to this racially decided independence from society fails to acknowledge their deep connection to their non-Jewish culture. Therefore, through an analysis of Deutschers work through the setting of Kafkas A Report to an Academy it becomes apparent that Deutscher undermines his argument by failing to appropriately state the relevance of the historical figures connection to society and intimately importantly, by allowing racial inflections to manipulate his perspective of his subject revolutionary individuals.